Democracy in Peril
On By Photomotoman In Far Right Conservatism Isn’t About Replacing Anything: It’s about Destroying What Exists, The FutureLeave a commentEdit
America’s march to the right has been thirty years in the making. The war between institutionalist supporters and anti-institutionalist believers has now reached its zenith with the election of Donald Trump.
The extreme right are now ensconced in a position of power that will let loose an era of retribution and effervescent hatred for anything described as liberal, neoliberal or “institutionalist”. America is in the throes of a shift that will likely release chaos internationally brought about by Republican’s thirty years of increasing distrust and anger towards the left.
Aaron Timms wrote an interesting article in the September, 2024 edition of the “New Republican” entitled “Rage and Confusion”, in which he outlined how the political ‘right’ were transformed in the 1990’s, and how that transformation laid the groundwork for the rise of Trump.
“How did we get from there to here? How did Trump, a figure of faint ridicule in the closing decades to the last century, become the defining figure of the American right in the opening decade of this one?
How indeed?
The article, is somewhat lengthy, but of great value in understanding the precursor political movement that created the conditions ripe for Trump to take advantage. Timms states;
“In Trump, the froth-era and fire breathers of the far right who tried and failed to penetrate the deepest centers of American power in the early 1990’s at last found their ideal messenger…the right-wing radicals of that era provided the foundation, as much in style as in content, for the shock of 2016 and the four-year carnival of xenophobia, anti-democratic provocation, and paper towel-tossing insensitivity that followed. David Duke, paleoconservative Pat Buchanan, shock jock Rush Limbaugh, New Right pamphleteer Sam Francis, election bomber Ross Perot, and mob boss John Gotti: These men walked so Donald Trump could run.”
The anti-liberal right, led by Perot, – like Trump, were deeply paranoid. But “Perot set a new ‘stylistic revolution’ in presidential campaigning: Perot showed that, in the cable era, vibes always trump policy detail.” And it released a groundswell of paranoia against the motives of the state, about political correctness, America’s changing demographics, about what Timms calls the “cultural encirclement of the left”.
From Daryl F. Gates brutality and racism in L.A., and the beating of Rodney King to the Idaho siege of Randy and Vicky Weaver and the siege of Ruby Ridge, as it became known, These propaganda victories for the far right became a “symbol of the forces driving alienation and political polarization across the nation.”
What was becoming evident was that characters like Rush Limbaugh, and from the pulpits of cable evangelism, Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson’s focuses on industrial decline, the cult of privatization, and a much-discussed national epidemic of loneliness created and gave rise to a “vast underground of discontent’ beneath the “calm surface of American life.”
America, throughout the 1990’s increasingly became a place of apprehension, fear and unease. “Globalism” was decried, and blamed for America’s foray into the Gulf War. Buchanan, once the Soviet Union’s threat was dispatched, allowed both he and Sam Francis (according to Timms) to “turn to the problem of how to overthrow democracy.”
However, to do so, the far-right needed a scape goat. That scape goat became “those who came from somewhere else: immigrants”.
Pamphleteer Francis, the intellectual inspiration behind the New Right stated that those who held their beliefs “could have no truck with the establishment, calling the New Right not conservative but a radical or revolutionary one. Mostly white and working class, they expected to “take back the country” and reject the politics of civility.
This time of intended “far-right cultural hegemony” led to Bannonism. American film fuelled this vision offering a powerful binary to explain America’s perceived decline. Timms suggests that Francis and Rothbard pined for a return to a social order built on the Godfather’s Machiavellian regime of hierarchy, fraud and force.
Jumping to Trump’s successes, Timms states, “The themes that Perot, Duke, Rothbard, Francis, Buchanan, and all the rest played on during that time are remarkably similar to those evoked by Trump today: a seething sense of national humiliation, the claim to speak for those left behind by progress, the urgent pledge to “take the country back” from the wokes and weaklings driving it to ruin.”
But the most important question remains. Now that Trump and his cronies possess the levers of power, how will the politics of resentment translate into policies that in fact improve America? What about America’s domestic agenda, – and how will this apparent focus on retribution serve America and Americans or the democracies and democratic institutions of the west?
What is coming appears to be unsettling. Tremors are already in evidence as the forces of disintegration of American values, and its institutions, – even its foreign policies are now thrown into question. America’s intended goal, voiced by Trump to serve America first, may lead to America being perceived as no longer the leader of what were America’s values a mere forty years ago.
If America itself is unwilling to stand against dictators and demagogues, then a rise in militarism, conflict and war is sure to follow. Even those nations that have generally eschewed violence and the use of military force, now find themselves in a race to militarize in order to protect their own sovereignty against aggression, as America retreats.
America now seeks protectionism and isolationism, – yet it expects to influence and lead the west politically. The two aims are completely incongruous, particularly as perceived by those nations that used to be influenced by American Foreign Policies. Trump, sees himself as Master of the Deal, – only if he can’t successfully be the Master of the Steal. Leading America’s retreat from a protector of democracy, to the Leader of American self-interest, further undermines America’s legitimacy in the eyes of other western nations.
A new political reality has been blasted through western democracies, further bolstering the far-right in all but three EU nations. America’s right-wing politics means liberal socialist values are now under attack.
It is important to remember, however that the last time America retreated from internationalism and sought isolationism, did not bode well for either America, democracy as an institution, or stability, globally.
America under Trump looks to become decidedly undemocratic. The far-right’s succession to power, actually has resulted in a vacuum within the international order. Which, as we know, both nature and geopolitics abhors. It is highly likely that in the near future, more nations – like Russia, will seek to fill the vacuum and resolve long standing disagreements with neighbours, now that the one-time superpower and global policeman has become simply the globe’s parking meter attendant.
It may well be easy to destroy and dismantle American democracy and its institutions. It will be much harder to create a functional, responsible and effective new government design, unless the objective was simply to create an autocratic and kleptocratic state.
One wonders.
If that is the intent. The New Right may well succeed, and by so doing, initiate a future more violent, hate-filled and retributive than even ‘they’ imagined, — as those seemingly deprived of democracy will not likely, go into that good night, peaceably.
Only time will tell.
“Rage and Confusion”, New Republic, September 2024, Timms, Aaron.
“The Year the Clock Broke”, Baffler, November/December 2018, Ganz, John.


Leave a Reply